String theory and an informationless zero ontology look like opposites. String theory appears to be the most baroque structure physics has ever produced: ten or eleven dimensions, Calabi-Yau compactifications, branes, and a landscape of perhaps 10⁵⁰⁰ vacua with different effective constants (String theory landscape). The zero ontology claims the total information content of reality is precisely zero: the superposition principle of quantum mechanics formalizes the default condition from which any notional departure would need to be explained, and because amplitudes are complex numbers, summed amplitudes can cancel to zero (IAI TV, Qualia Computing). The reconciliation turns on three moves.
1. The landscape is an index set, not a problem. The standard complaint against the landscape is that it destroys predictivity: something must select a vacuum, via anthropics plus a measure over eternal inflation (Douglas, Universe). On the zero-ontology reading, nothing is selected. Every consistent vacuum is instantiated as a component of the universal wave function, and the question "why these constants?" dissolves indexically rather than anthropically: observers find themselves in a life-permitting branch of a superposition whose total vector carries no net information. Crucially, the zero ontology does not need a measure over the landscape. The measure problem presupposes that a probability distribution is extra structure added to the wave function; if the components cancel, the ensemble is a single structureless vector, and zero is the one quantity that is basis-independent.
2. Necessity carries no information. Whatever is mathematically forced carries zero bits in the relevant sense: "2 + 2 = 4" selects nothing, so specifying it adds no information. Anomaly cancellation, the critical dimension, the uniqueness of consistent string perturbation theories, and the swampland constraints that prune the space of effective theories compatible with quantum gravity all point the same way: string theory's apparent richness is largely theorems, not choices (Theories of Anything overview). The zero ontologist should welcome every result that shrinks the landscape toward a unique consistency-determined structure, because the residual information to cancel shrinks with it. The worst-case scenario for this reconciliation would be a final theory with genuinely arbitrary input; the best case is a theory where nothing could have been otherwise, in which case the question "why this theory?" is answered the same way as "why does anything exist?": there is nothing to explain.
3. Holography as compression toward zero. The holographic principle, a property of string theories, states that a volume's description can be encoded on a lower-dimensional boundary, inspired by the Bekenstein bound and the black hole area law (Holographic principle). Duality is information-preserving redundancy: a bulk string theory and its boundary conformal field theory are one description, not two. For the zero ontology this matters twice over. It shows that apparent descriptive excess is compressible, and it supplies the mechanism by which a closed universe can self-cancel: if everything inside a horizon is a re-encoding of the boundary, there is no residue of information that must, on pain of paradox, be accounted for from outside.
Where the tension genuinely remains
Honesty requires flagging what is not yet reconciled.
Background dependence. Perturbative string theory presupposes a spacetime background; a full non-perturbative definition of M-theory does not exist yet. A zero ontology wants the final, background-independent state, and string theory cannot currently supply one. The reconciliation is promissory at exactly the point where string theory itself is promissory.
Cancellation is conjectured, not derived. No calculation shows that the wave function over the landscape sums to zero. The zero ontology is a conjecture about the total; string theory at best provides a candidate space of components, not the proof of their cancellation.
The Born measure. Even if the total is zero-information, the mod-squared-amplitude weighting that makes individual branches statistical is not itself obviously information-free. This is inherited from Everett rather than caused by strings, but the reconciliation does not discharge it.
Your own variant adds a further constraint. On a non-materialist physicalist reading where the physical is experiential, string theory must ultimately describe the quantum field theory whose states are phenomenal; whether the mathematics of extended objects can play that role is orthogonal to the zero-information claim and unanswered by it.
Bottom line
The two are not rivals at the same level. The zero ontology answers "why is there something rather than nothing?"; string theory, if true, describes the dynamical regularities inside the zero-information whole. They reconcile to the extent that string theory's structure is (i) consistency-necessitated rather than chosen, (ii) exhaustively instantiated in superposition so that nothing is selected from it, and (iii) holographically compressible. They remain unreconciled to the extent that string theory still lacks its background-independent, uniquely-determined formulation, and that the exact cancellation remains a metaphysical conjecture rather than a theorem (Witherall's critical discussion is a fair statement of what remains vulnerable).
Nov 8, 10:01pm
This is a shared conversation and may include unverified content that doesn't reflect Mistral AI's views. Login to resume chatting.
This is a shared conversation and may include unverified content that doesn't reflect Mistral AI's views. Login to resume chatting.