The research base is in place. Now I'll write the full essay as a canvas document.
A Hedonic Kardashev Scale: Classifying Civilizations by Hedonic Range
I've developed the full proposal in a new canvas, "A Hedonic Kardashev Scale: Classifying Civilizations by Hedonic Range." The skeleton of it:
The scale. It formalizes the −10→+10 vs. +70→+100 schematic from the Sentience Research interview into a civilizational ladder — H⁻ (hellworlds), H-0 (Darwinian), H-1 (abolitionist: floor at hedonic zero), H-2 (hyperthymic), H-3 (superbliss) — scored on a profile of floor, set-point, ceiling, gradient resolution and reach, with hedonic zero as a non-arbitrary origin (unlike QALY anchors). Ranking is lexicographic on the floor first (negative-utilitarian maximin), and the scale structurally rewards uplift, never subtraction — so omnicide can't score as progress.
Measurability. Ratio-scale within persons is psychophysically routine; interpersonal comparison at interval level is a live programme (conjoint measurement, Berridge's hedonic-hotspot neurochemistry — noting liking ≠ dopaminergic wanting, so naive "reward" measures fail); cross-species is already institutionalized via pain-hours metrics; radical minds await a mature consciousness science — your non-materialist physicalism and QRI's valence formalism being the rival candidate frameworks.
The three candidate ceilings:
Quantum binding — the only candidate hard limit, and conditional: if binding is quantum, decoherence (Tegmark: ~10⁻¹³–10⁻²⁰ s; tryptophan superradiance suggests warm coherence is real but far short of brain-scale) caps the coherence envelope of a single unified moment — so superbliss would be modular and plural, a ceiling on the unit, not the sum.
Metabolism — no ceiling: the hedonic treadmill is a selection artefact, not thermodynamics; nothing couples joules to hedons (Landauer prices computation, not valence).
Information-processing — no absolute cap, but a structural law: gradients must remain resolvable, so the ceiling can never collapse onto the floor. The "compass stuck on north" objection rules out uniform bliss, not elevated bliss — the contrast relocates to +70-to-+100.
The surprising upshot: whether the universe has a maximum size of joy turns on the binding problem — if phenomenal binding is quantum, decoherence is the true ceiling; if not, the scale is open-ended above hedonic zero.
Nov 5, 10:42am
This is a shared conversation and may include unverified content that doesn't reflect Mistral AI's views. Login to resume chatting.
This is a shared conversation and may include unverified content that doesn't reflect Mistral AI's views. Login to resume chatting.