Oct 28, 7:59am

The Steelman for The Hedonistic Imperative

Here is the strongest case that can be made, stated so a critic would recognize it as the best version of the argument.

1. Start from the point of maximal agreement. Almost every moral system, religious or secular, treats suffering as bad and its reduction as urgent. Disagreement begins only over what else matters — virtue, autonomy, meaning, desert. The abolitionist project needs nothing from those contested regions. It requires only the minimal, near-universal premise: in itself, suffering is bad, and the world would be better without it. If any moral claim is secure, that one is. A steelman exploits this: HI doesn't ask you to accept utilitarianism, only the asymmetry virtually everyone already accepts when it's their own child screaming.

2. The descriptive claim: suffering is an engineered artifact, not a metaphysical necessity. Evolution built pain as a fitness device, and it built it badly — brutally, bluntly, and with no regard for the experiencer. The crucial empirical observation is that nociception and the felt nastiness of pain are dissociable: people with pain asymbolia and congenital insensitivity to pain alleles (e.g., SCN9A loss-of-function) respond to damaging stimuli and report pain sensations without the affective agonism. This proves the aversive component is a genetically tunable dial, not an inseparable essence of embodiment. If suffering is a codebase, it can be rewritten. The question is not whether but when, how, and by whom.

3. The scope claim: the victims vastly outnumber us. The moral circle hasn't stopped at the human boundary in over a century — each expansion once seemed radical and now seems obvious. Non-human vertebrates, and plausibly many invertebrates, are sentient by the same behavioral, pharmacological, and neurobiological criteria we use on each other. On any sober accounting, the overwhelming majority of suffering in the world occurs in wild animals and in factory farming — hundreds of billions of beings, per year, none of whom consented to Darwinian life. HI is the only framework that takes this scale seriously rather than as an occasion for poetry about nature's majesty. Nature is not a sanctuary; it's an ongoing atrocity with excellent optics.

4. The wirehead objection is answered before it's raised. The standard objection — that engineered bliss collapses into motivational flatline, a static Nirvana of grinning vegetables — rests on conflating reward with reward gradient. Nothing in physics or information theory says motivation requires suffering; it requires differences. A mind whose baseline is sublime and whose gradients are informationally rich can still solve equations, fall in love, and pursue truth — indeed, with hyper-dopaminergic vigor, likely better than we do. Depression and anxiety are not the engine of human achievement; they're the friction. The claim "no pain, no gain" is an empirical hypothesis about human wetware, and it's false.

5. The status quo is not a neutral option. The strongest rhetorical move: not redesigning the reward architecture is itself an ongoing moral choice with billions of victims per year. We already accept wholesale intervention in suffering's machinery — analgesics, anesthetics, vaccines, the eradication of smallpox. Nobody calls the WHO totalitarian for deleting variola. Objections to germ-line abolition typically rest on status quo bias and a quasi-religious essentialism about "human nature" — the same intuition that opposed vaccination, and for the same reason: the yuck factor at intervening in what feels natural. The steelman doesn't argue that intervention is safe and easy; it argues that the alternatives being defended have an unacknowledged body count, and that this is exactly the kind of situation where the point is not to predict what suffering-free minds would choose but to acknowledge they wouldn't choose Auschwitz.

6. The asymmetry seals it. Suppose HI fails: we attempt abolition, something goes wrong, we get a worse world. That's a serious risk, and the steelman owns it — HI is explicitly not a utopian claim of instant success, but a long-horizon, iterative, technically demanding project. But now run the reverse: we don't attempt it, and nothing goes wrong — meaning we simply continue as-is. In that "success" case, tens of billions of sentient beings suffer and die pointlessly every year, forever. So the cost of inaction is not zero and not hypothetical; it is the present, occurring now, at scale. Against that baseline, abolition doesn't need a guarantee of success — only a credible probability of getting it right eventually, and that's all it claims.

7. The endgame. What HI proposes is not the abolition of anything anyone would miss — only of the aversive component of experience — while keeping, and amplifying, motivation, intellect, aesthetics, love, and open-ended curiosity. A civilization of beings living lives of superhuman bliss, exploring the universe, doing philosophy, and caring for each other and the biosphere is not a lower state than ours. It is what we would already call a triumph, if we could bear to admit that we were the mud from which it grew.

In sum: The Hedonistic Imperative is nothing more than a conjunction of three claims — suffering is intrinsically bad; suffering is a contingent biological feature that science can plausibly edit; and therefore, we should. The first is accepted by nearly everyone, the second is a molecular-biological fact in progress, and the third is entailed. All the real work of the steelman lies not in the conclusion but in dispelling the suspicion that we must keep suffering around because it's somehow doing us a favor — it isn't, and Darwin, unlike us, never cared either way.

Happy to extend this into a piece for the second edition, reframe it as an anticipation of specific critics, or write the corresponding "best case against" for balance.

Oct 28, 7:59am

This is a shared conversation and may include unverified content that doesn't reflect Mistral AI's views. Login to resume chatting.

Vibe can make mistakes. Check answers. Learn more