Yes, several. The conjecture has two separable parts: (1) the philosophical claim that phenomenal binding is classically impossible, and (2) the physical claim that neuronal feature-processors sustain quantum-coherent superpositions at sub-femtosecond timescales. Only (2) is directly experimentally addressable, and matter-wave interferometry is just one witness of it. Here are alternatives, roughly in order of nearness to existing labs:
Coherence witnesses that don't require extracting molecules
NMR multiple-quantum-coherence (MQC) entanglement witnesses. Kerskens and Pérez adapted the Bose/Marletto–Vedral mediator protocol to human brains in an MRI scanner and reported a signal with no classical NMR contrast that tracked conscious awareness and working-memory performance. A rigorous replication, ideally with anesthetic dose-response and sleep/wake controls, would be a non-invasive test of non-classicality in the living brain (Kerskens & Pérez, 2022, Wiest's 2025 review). Caveat: contested (Warren 2023), and it witnesses non-classicality of some unknown mediator, not specifically superposed feature-processors.
NV-diamond magnetometry next to neurons. A genuine superposition of distinct charge distributions radiates no classical dipole field; only decoherence events do. NV centres can already optically detect single-neuron action potentials (Levine et al., microscopic brain recording), so the anomaly hunt would be for missing or anomalous radiation, or decoherence "flashes" time-locked to binding-like events in a cortical slice. Conceptually this is the closest in spirit to your protocol: it tests the quasi-classicality of neurons directly, in situ.
Ultrafast 2D electronic/vibrational spectroscopy on candidate substrates (tubulin, membrane proteins, vesicles) from living networks versus fixed controls. Any measured coherence lifetime is informative: the conjecture needs sustained coherent frames, so either you find unexpectedly long-lived coherences or you bound them. Anesthetics become a perturbation knob: does isoflurane at behaviorally relevant concentrations selectively collapse the measured coherences?
Spin-based tests. Electron spin resonance of anesthetic-bound candidate proteins: if anesthetic potency tracks disruption of coherent spin states (e.g., delocalised electrons in tubulin's aromatic residues), that's a spin-channel analogue of your interferometer, and it's within reach of existing ESR labs.
Collective-excitation witnesses. Room-temperature superradiance from microtubule tryptophan networks (Babcock et al. 2024) and the Bandyopadhyay resonance experiments are already witnesses of collective coherent states; the decisive additions are anesthetic quenching and consciousness-state dependence (summary).
Perturbation experiments (testing the causal role, not just presence)
Microtubule-pharmacology dose-response. Wiest's epothilone B result (stabilising microtubules delays anesthetic-induced unconsciousness in rats) is exactly this logic (Medical Xpress). The extension that would speak to binding specifically: sub-anesthetic doses of coherence-disrupting drugs should produce graded, reversible deficits in Gestalt-binding psychophysics (ambiguous figures, illusory contours, asynchrony binding windows) while sparing classical signal transmission.
Resonant perturbation. If a specific collective vibrational or spin mode carries the binding coherence, driving it resonantly (THz/IR for vibrations, RF for spins) should selectively disrupt binding tasks. This is the magnetoreception paradigm transplanted to binding: cheap, falsifiable, and it identifies a mechanism rather than a mere anomaly.
Isotope substitution, Fisher-style. If particular nuclear spins mediate the coherence, isotope effects should appear in binding performance (the lithium-6/lithium-7 behavioural divergence in rodents is the template). Novel, and no one has run a binding-task version.
Indirect and theoretical cross-checks
Collapse-model experiments elsewhere. Optomechanical and levitated-nanoparticle tests of CSL/gravity-related collapse don't touch a brain, but pinning down collapse rates in the relevant mass/duration regime would either license or forbid ms-scale superpositions of neuronal-sized systems, settling the "reductio ad absurdum" objection by proxy.
Emission-deficit test. Dense electrode reconstruction of cortical current sources versus measured far-field radiation: a systematic deficit in dipole emission correlated with conscious processing would be a direct signature of superposed charge distributions. Extremely hard, but it tests the conjecture at the level of whole neurons rather than any candidate molecule.
Ghose's emergent-Schrödinger proposal suggests looking for quantum fluctuations in subthreshold neural oscillations (arXiv 2406.16991), a cheap signature hunt if his derivation holds up.
A structural asymmetry is worth keeping in view: most of these are witnesses of non-classicality, so a positive result supports but doesn't uniquely confirm the binding role, whereas your interferometry null would be a clean falsification. The perturbation family (anesthetics, resonant driving, isotope substitution) is the only route that could show superposition doing binding work, so a combined program, coherence witness plus coherence perturbation with a binding readout, is probably the strongest alternative to the interferometer.
If you're weighing what to add to the second edition of Can Biotechnology Abolish Suffering?, the Kerskens–Pérez and Wiest results are the most citable post-2017 developments on this front (No access).
2/2
Nov 12, 1:18pm
This is a shared conversation and may include unverified content that doesn't reflect Mistral AI's views. Login to resume chatting.
This is a shared conversation and may include unverified content that doesn't reflect Mistral AI's views. Login to resume chatting.