Good initial sweep. Let me run a second round to pin down a few key items.
Here are 10 philosophical updates since the essays on hedweb.com were written (most post-2017), each relevant to the Abolitionist Project, consciousness, or sentience-explosion material — and complementary to the biotech corrections already flagged in your second-edition memo (No access).
IIT emerged battered from adversarial testing (2025). The Cogitate collaboration's results, published in Nature, gave mixed support to both integrated information theory and global workspace theory, leaving no confirmed theory of consciousness. (Nature) Worth updating the consciousness essays' reliance on IIT accordingly.
Jonathan Birch's The Edge of Sentience (2024) offers a precautionary, decision-theoretic framework for attributing sentience under uncertainty, explicitly covering animals and AI. (Oxford Academic) This gives hedweb's welfare-biology claims a rigorous, citable methodology.
The New York Declaration on Animal Consciousness (April 2024), signed by hundreds of scientists, holds there is a "realistic possibility" of consciousness in all vertebrates and many invertebrates, including insects. (NYU declaration, Philosophers News) A major burden-of-proof shift in favour of the abolitionist moral circle.
Invertebrate sentience went legal and quantitative. The UK's Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act 2022 was extended to decapod crustaceans and cephalopod molluscs after the LSE review. (legislation.gov.uk, LSE) Meanwhile Rethink Priorities published welfare-range estimates for dozens of species, and "Rethinking Sentience" (2024) argues invertebrates merit moral consideration. (Rethink Priorities, Springer)
Wild-animal suffering became a live academic debate. The movement against wild animal suffering is now discussed in conservation science, while philosophers attack "interventionism" as anthropocentric. (Oryx, Biology & Philosophy, Rethink Priorities) Hedweb's compassionate-stewardship essays could engage both sides.
Chalmers asked "Could a Large Language Model be Conscious?" (2023), arguing no current LLM meets even functionalist criteria, but foreseeing no principled barrier for successors with recurrence and world-models. (arXiv) A direct bridge from the "Sentience Explosion" essay to current AI.
AI welfare became a research field. Jeff Sebo's The Moral Circle (2025) argues for including AI among moral patients, and a 2025 Philosophical Studies literature addresses individuating artificial moral patients. (Google Books, Springer, Brookings) The "Welfare of Digital Minds" research agenda formalizes the topic. (EA Forum)
S-risks entered mainstream philosophy journals. "AI welfare risks" and "Is there a tension between AI safety and AI welfare?" (both Philosophical Studies, 2025) examine worst-case digital suffering and whether welfare concerns could clash with safety measures. (Springer, Springer) Useful for the negative-utilitarian strand of hedweb.
The procreation asymmetry gained rigorous defenses. Johann Frick's defense of the asymmetry appeared in the Journal of Moral Philosophy (2025), alongside a growing literature (e.g. in Analysis and Utilitas) on why creating suffering lives is wrong while creating happy lives is optional. (Brill, Analysis, Utilitas) This counters the old charge that abolitionism rests on ad hoc intuitions.
Suffering-focused consequentialism is getting dedicated metaethical scrutiny. A 2025 Journal of the Indian Council of Philosophical Research cluster examines metaethical foundations of suffering-focused ethics and whether introspection of "moral qualia" grounds pain's badness. (Springer, Springer) Sign of the view moving from fringe to debatable orthodoxy.
If you'd like, I can draft hedweb-friendly prose for any of these, or fold them into the second-edition update plan as a "philosophical developments" section.
Nov 8, 10:49pm
This is a shared conversation and may include unverified content that doesn't reflect Mistral AI's views. Login to resume chatting.
This is a shared conversation and may include unverified content that doesn't reflect Mistral AI's views. Login to resume chatting.